Skip to story
ELI5 Yahaaa

A judgement, not a species

What Makes a Plant a Weed?

No plant is a weed. A weed is any plant growing where somebody did not want it.

In a flowerbed A weed — pull it outIn a meadow A wildflower — leaveit alone
Same plant. The difference is where it is standing.
  1. Step 1 of 5

    There is no weed family in biology.

    Has a species and afamilyHas flowers, leavesand rootsHas no scientificcategory called weedOnly a person cancall it one

    A botanist can tell you a plant's family and its name, but nothing in it says weed. That word describes what a person thinks of it.

  2. Step 2 of 5

    The same plant swaps sides depending on the field.

    Wheat in a wheat field A cropWheat in a barley field A weed

    Wheat growing in a barley field is a weed. Mint in a border is a menace and mint in a pot is a herb.

  3. Step 3 of 5

    Still, the plants we call weeds tend to share a few habits.

    Grows fastSets seed youngMakes thousands ofseedsLoves freshly dugground

    They grow fast, set seed early, make an enormous number of seeds — a single fat hen plant can set tens of thousands. And they thrive on bare disturbed ground, which is exactly what a garden or a field is.

  4. Step 4 of 5

    And many can come back from a scrap left behind.

    1 The root snapsas you pull2 Each piece isstill alive3 Two plantswhere therewas one

    Break a dandelion root and each piece can grow a new plant. Bindweed and couch grass do the same, which is why digging can spread them.

  5. Step 5 of 5

    So weeding is gardening, not biology.

    Ground is cleared Fast plantsarrive first They get pulledout

    You are not removing a category of plant. You are deciding what grows where, and the plants are simply very good at the ground you keep clearing.

    Several plants sold in supermarkets — dandelion leaves, nettles, purslane — are weeds somewhere else in the same week.

The short version

A weed is not a type of plant but a judgement about place — though the plants earning the name are usually fast, seedy and fond of disturbed ground.

Try it yourself

Look at a plant somebody is about to pull up and ask what would change if it were three metres to the left. Usually, everything.

Tags