Skip to story
ELI5 Yahaaa

The same temperature, treated gently

Why Do Cooks Simmer Instead of Boil?

A rolling boil is not hotter than a simmer — it is just rougher.

Rolling boil 100 °C, and thrashingSimmer Also 100 °C, and calm
Turning the heat up does not make the water hotter.
  1. Step 1 of 5

    Water stops getting hotter at its boiling point.

    Cold watertemperatureclimbingNearly boilingstill climbingBoiling hardstuck at 100 —the extra makessteam

    Once it reaches 100 degrees, extra heat goes into turning liquid into steam instead of raising the temperature. The thermometer simply stops.

  2. Step 2 of 5

    So a fierce boil only makes more steam.

    More heat in More steam outNot one degree hotter

    A high flame produces bubbles faster and empties the pan quicker, but every part of the food is sitting in water at exactly the same temperature.

  3. Step 3 of 5

    The violence is what damages food.

    Simmered Pieces stay intactBoiled hard Everything breaks apart

    Bubbles knock delicate things apart. Fish flakes, eggs toughen, and a stew's vegetables collapse into the sauce instead of staying whole.

  4. Step 4 of 5

    A simmer holds the heat steadier too.

    A pan on low heatEnough heat tocook throughLittle enoughto keep theliquid

    A gentle pan keeps its lid's worth of heat with little evaporation, so the liquid level and the seasoning stay where the cook put them.

  5. Step 5 of 5

    Which is why recipes are fussy about the words.

    1 One bubbleevery second ortwo2 A continuouschurn3 Both at 100 °C

    A simmer shows a bubble every second or two. A rolling boil is a continuous churn. They cook at the same temperature but produce different food.

    A pressure cooker is the exception — it raises the boiling point itself, so the water really does get hotter.

The short version

Boiling and simmering are the same temperature, so a fierce boil adds only steam and damage, never heat.

Try it yourself

Put a thermometer in gently simmering water, then turn the flame to full. The reading does not move.

Topics