Skip to story
ELI5 Yahaaa

Bread would be fine

What If Every Bee Vanished?

We would not starve. We would lose almost everything worth eating.

Pollinated by wind Wheat, rice, maize —most of the world'scaloriesPollinated by animals Apples, almonds,coffee, cocoa, mostfruit
The first group would not notice. The second one is the whole problem.
  1. Step 1 of 5

    The big staple crops never needed bees.

    Wind carries thepollen Grasses need novisitors at all

    Wheat, rice, maize, barley and oats are grasses, and grasses are pollinated by wind. Between them they supply most of the calories eaten on Earth, and not one of them would be affected.

  2. Step 2 of 5

    But the plate loses its colour.

    Crops that needpollinatorsCrops that do not
    Not the calories. The reasons for eating.

    Roughly a third of what we eat by volume depends on animal pollinators. It is the interesting third: apples, cherries, blueberries, melons, almonds, avocados, cucumbers, coffee and cocoa all go.

  3. Step 3 of 5

    Some of it can be done by hand — badly.

    A bee Thousands of flowersa day, freeA person with a brush A few hundred a day,paid

    Where pollinators have already been lost, people do the job with brushes, flower by flower. It works, and it is so slow and expensive that it is only ever worth it for high-value crops.

  4. Step 4 of 5

    Bees are not the only pollinators.

    Bees Butterfliesand moths Beetles Birds andbats

    Butterflies, moths, hoverflies, beetles, wasps, bats and birds all carry pollen. Some plants depend on exactly one of them — a fig has its own species of wasp and nothing else will do.

  5. Step 5 of 5

    It is not all-or-nothing, and that is the actual worry.

    Enough pollinatorsfull harvestSomewhat fewersmaller,patchier fruitNoticeably fewerthe crop stopsbeing worthgrowing

    No one expects every bee to vanish at once. What is happening is a slow thinning — fewer species, fewer individuals, in more places. A crop does not fail when the last bee goes; it fails when there are not quite enough.

    Why bees bother with flowers at all — and why they stay loyal to one kind at a time — is its own page.

The short version

Losing every bee would not cost us bread or rice; it would cost us fruit, coffee, chocolate and most of what makes food interesting.

Try it yourself

Look at a plate and sort it into wind-pollinated and animal-pollinated. The bread and rice stay. Almost nothing else does.

Tags