Skip to story
ELI5 Yahaaa

A fruit with no seeds and no parents

Why Are Bananas All the Same?

Every banana in the shop is a cutting from the same plant, which is why they are identical and why they are in trouble.

A wild banana Packed with hardseedsA shop banana No seeds, and no wayto breed
The useful one is the one that cannot reproduce.
  1. Step 1 of 5

    Wild bananas are full of seeds.

    A wild banana, cutacross Mostly hard seeds

    A wild banana is mostly hard black seeds with a little flesh between them. It is barely worth eating, and the seeds are how the plant makes more of itself.

  2. Step 2 of 5

    The edible ones are a mistake that stuck.

    1 A plant with anodd chromosomecount2 It cannot formseeds3 All flesh, andworth growing

    A rare plant ended up with an extra set of chromosomes, which left it unable to make seeds. That failure is exactly what made it good to eat.

  3. Step 3 of 5

    So every plant is a cutting.

    A shoot takenfrom the parent Planted, andgeneticallyidentical

    With no seeds, the only way to make more is to take a shoot from an existing plant. Every banana of a variety is a piece of one original plant, still growing.

  4. Step 4 of 5

    Identical means uniform, which is why they are cheap.

    Bananas from fourdifferent farmsGenetically, all thesame plant

    Every plant ripens at the same time, to the same size, with the same taste. That is what makes shipping bananas across the world at low cost possible at all.

  5. Step 5 of 5

    And identical means one disease can take them all.

    A varied crop Some plants survivean outbreakAn identical one One disease reachesall of it

    If a fungus can kill one plant it can kill every plant. That has already happened once: the variety sold before the 1950s was wiped out and replaced.

    A banana plant is not a tree. It has no wood at all — the trunk is tightly rolled leaf bases, which is why one storm can flatten a plantation.

The short version

Shop bananas are seedless cuttings of a single plant, which makes them uniform and cheap and leaves them defenceless against disease.

Try it yourself

Look closely at the middle of a banana slice. The tiny black specks are the seeds it can no longer make.

Tags