Skip to story
ELI5 Yahaaa

Notes that share their wobbles

Why Does Singing Together Sound Good?

Some pairs of notes lock together and sound sweet; others fight and sound rough. It comes down to simple arithmetic.

Simple ratio The waves line up — itsounds sweetAwkward ratio They clash — it soundsrough
Arithmetic you can hear.
  1. Step 1 of 5

    An octave is exactly double.

    The low notewobbles thisfastThe octave aboveexactly twice asfast

    A note vibrating twice as fast as another sounds so alike that both get the same name. Every two waves of the high note fit one of the low — the simplest possible fit.

  2. Step 2 of 5

    Other sweet pairs are simple fractions.

    Two to one: the octaveThree to two: brightand openFour to three: settledand warmSixteen to fifteen:tense and grinding

    Three wobbles against two, or four against three, also line up neatly and sound pleasant. The simpler the fraction, the more settled the pair sounds together.

  3. Step 3 of 5

    Clashing notes beat against each other.

    Two nearly-equalnotes They drift in andout of step

    Two notes very slightly apart drift in and out of step, and you hear the loudness pulsing. That throbbing is the roughness — and singers use it to tune themselves.

  4. Step 4 of 5

    Harmony is people choosing simple ratios.

    The low partthe base of thechordThe middle partfour to threeabove itThe high partthree to twoabove that

    A choir singing in parts is several people holding notes in those neat fractions at once. It sounds full because the waves fit together instead of grinding.

  5. Step 5 of 5

    Singing together locks people in.

    Someone drifts slightly off The roughnessis heard atonce Everyone corrects towards each other The grouplockstogether

    Voices in a group drift towards each other, because the roughness of being slightly off is unpleasant and everyone corrects it. Breathing falls in step too, which is part of why it feels good.

    Different musical traditions cut the octave into different numbers of steps. The octave itself is agreed on everywhere, because doubling is not a matter of taste.

The short version

Notes sound good together when their vibrations fit simple whole-number ratios, and rough when they nearly but do not quite match.

Try it yourself

Get two people to hum the same note and have one bend slowly away. The throbbing you hear appears exactly as they part.

Topics