Skip to story
ELI5 Yahaaa

Light changing lanes

Why Does a Straw Look Bent?

Light slows down entering water, and slowing at an angle makes it turn.

1 A straightstraw2 Light leavesthe water at anangle3 It lookssnapped in half
The straw is fine. The light is not going straight.
  1. Step 1 of 5

    Light travels slower in water than in air.

    Air300,000 km/sWater225,000 km/sDiamond124,000 km/s

    Water molecules get in the way, dropping light from 300,000 to about 225,000 km per second. Glass slows it more still.

  2. Step 2 of 5

    Hitting a boundary at an angle makes it turn.

    Straight on Slows, does not turnAt an angle One edge slows first —it turns

    If a beam meets the surface slanted, one side crosses first and slows first. The whole beam pivots — exactly like a trolley with one wheel hitting sand.

  3. Step 3 of 5

    Your brain refuses to believe it.

    1 Light bendsleaving thewater2 Brain assumesit camestraight3 Underwater partappears shifted

    Your visual system always assumes light arrived in a straight line. It traces the bent rays back along a straight path and puts the underwater part of the straw in the wrong place.

  4. Step 4 of 5

    It is why water looks shallower than it is.

    Where the fish looks Higher and closerWhere the fish is Deeper than it appears

    The same bending makes the bottom of a pool appear about a quarter closer than it really is. Spear fishers learn to aim below the fish.

  5. Step 5 of 5

    Push the angle far enough and light cannot get out at all.

    Shallow angle Light escapes, bentPast the critical angle Totally reflected backinside

    Beyond a certain angle, light hitting the underside of the surface reflects back down instead of escaping. Fibre optic cables use this to trap light for thousands of kilometres.

    Refraction is also why the setting Sun is visible after it has actually dropped below the horizon.

The short version

Light bends when it changes speed at a boundary, and your straight-line brain misplaces whatever it came from.

Try it yourself

Put a coin in an empty mug and back away until it just disappears behind the rim. Pour in water and it reappears.

Topics