Skip to story
ELI5 Yahaaa

Fitting one place very well

Why Does Every Animal Live Somewhere Different?

A polar bear would die in a desert and a camel would die on the ice. Being superb somewhere means being hopeless elsewhere.

On the ice Thick fat, smallears, huge feetIn the desert Long legs, no fatlayer, huge feet
Both perfectly built. Neither could swap.
  1. Step 1 of 5

    A habitat is a set of problems.

    TemperatureToo hot, or toocoldWaterEverywhere, oralmost nowhereFood and safetyWhat growsthere, and whathunts there

    Every place asks the same questions in different ways: how to stay the right temperature, find water, find food and not be eaten. The answers only work locally.

  2. Step 2 of 5

    Being good at one thing costs another.

    A thick coatSuperb on the iceFatal in the heat

    Thick fur is wonderful on ice and fatal in a desert. Every feature that solves one place's problem well makes another place's problem worse.

  3. Step 3 of 5

    So animals specialise.

    Places it is superbPlaces it would notlast a week

    Rather than being adequate everywhere, animals get very good at one place. Competition pushes them into it: whoever fits a place best keeps it.

  4. Step 4 of 5

    Layers within one place count too.

    CanopyLeaves, light,birds andmonkeysTrunksBark, insects,climbersLeaf litterDamp, dark,worms and fungi

    A single forest holds several habitats stacked up. Animals in the canopy, the trunks and the leaf litter live metres apart and never really meet.

  5. Step 5 of 5

    Which is why losing a habitat matters.

    The habitat goes The animals builtfor it havenowhere to fit

    An animal built for one place cannot simply move. Clear the forest and the animals that fit it have nowhere to go that they are any good at.

    Some animals go the other way and specialise in change itself. Rats, pigeons and foxes fit almost anywhere, which is why cities are full of them.

The short version

Each animal is shaped by the problems of one place, and being superb there is exactly what makes it useless elsewhere.

Try it yourself

Look at what lives under a log, on the log, and in the tree above it. Three habitats within arm's reach.

Tags