Skip to story
ELI5 Yahaaa

Lighter than air, and too slow

Why Did Airships Stop Flying?

An airship floats without moving and needs almost no fuel to stay up. It disappeared anyway, and fire is only part of the reason.

An aeroplane Stays up by movingfastAn airship Stays up by weighingless than the air
Two completely different ways of not falling.
  1. Step 1 of 5

    Anything lighter than the air it displaces floats.

    Displaces a hugevolume of air The air around itpushes upward

    A balloon rises for the same reason a cork rises in water. Push the air aside with something lighter and the surrounding air pushes it upward.

  2. Step 2 of 5

    Which means it needs an enormous volume.

    A large aeroplaneCarries hundredsAn airship of the same lengthCarries a fewdozen

    Air is very light, so lifting anything useful means displacing a great deal of it. An airship carrying a few dozen people has to be longer than a football pitch.

  3. Step 3 of 5

    Hydrogen lifts best and burns.

    Hydrogen Best lift, and itburnsHelium Safe, but scarce andheavier

    The lightest usable gas is hydrogen, and it catches fire readily. Helium is safe and lifts nearly as well, but it was scarce and controlled by one country at the time.

  4. Step 4 of 5

    Size is the real problem.

    WindA huge sailthat cannot beloweredMooringDozens ofpeople neededon the groundWeatherCannot climbabove a storm

    Something that big is at the mercy of the wind, needs a crowd of people to moor it, and cannot be flown through weather an aeroplane simply climbs above.

  5. Step 5 of 5

    Aeroplanes got fast, and that settled it.

    Airship crossingTwo or threedaysAeroplane crossingHours

    An airship crossed the Atlantic in two or three days. Once aeroplanes could do it in hours, floating gently stopped being worth anything to a passenger.

    A handful still fly, mostly as camera platforms over sports events, where hovering quietly for hours is exactly the point.

The short version

An airship floats by weighing less than the air it displaces, but its size made it slow and weather-bound, and aeroplanes won.

Try it yourself

Let a helium balloon go in a room with a draught. It has no way to resist being pushed around.

Tags